Tenth Circuit Upholds $115K Fee Award Despite Defense Team's AI Use

Tenth Circuit Upholds $115K Fee Award Despite Defense Team's AI Use

The Common Question

Does using AI in legal work reduce the fees a losing party must pay?

The Lesson in This Case

Flux Drive must pay the full $115,000 in legal fees awarded to defense firm Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck after a unanimous Tenth Circuit panel rejected the argument that AI assistance warranted a reduction. The court found that because defense attorneys personally verified all AI-assisted research and arguments, the billing remained reasonable, and the plaintiff identified no specific charge that was inflated or redundant. Senior leaders budgeting for AI-assisted professional services should note that courts are treating human verification as the standard that justifies full billing rates, and AI use alone gives a losing party no grounds to demand a discount.

Originally reported by ABA Journal. Read the full story here.